Learning to See, Part VII
Article from Digital Photography School
Whereas photography is about vision, composition is about aesthetics.
In our previous readings in this series we learned how colour, contrast and tonal range have a dramatic effect on the overall result. Some teachers may say the first important rule in making successful pictures is composition, and indeed that may be so. However, I also like my intrepid readers to be unique and true to themselves. Therefore, let’s argue that colour impact is more important than composition ( remember folks, this series is for the novice and beginner so please let’s not start a raging debate and muddle the waters. I want our beginners to have fun and explore for themselves – they will figure it out.)
I had the good fortune of being raised in the country, on a twisting gravel road that followed a meandering river. Not far from the family farm was one of those old-styled triangular framed bridges that crossed the river, and just beyond that was a drumlin where one could sit and breathe in the unfolding landscape below. It was idyllic, and a magnet for artists easels.
When my daily chores were finished I would often climb aboard the 28-inch hand-me-down bicycle, with worms in pocket and alder fishing pole, and peddle to my secret fishing hole. Sometimes I would arrive at my destination, other times I would be sidetracked by an artist standing atop the Lloyd Hill (as we called the drumlin), adorned in beret with brushes in hand.
Invariably each artist would add the S-curve of the river leading in from the bottom right corner of the blank canvas following a diagonal until it exited in the upper left corner. The triangular bridge was always in the bottom right-hand corner of the canvas, our farm in the upper right hand corner. The distant pine forests would create the far-off horizon line. One artist who often visited the same location would place an elm tree in the left foreground of the scene to add balance and colour, reflecting the season. Ironically, the elm was not in the vista lying before her eyes, but was a creation of her imagination.
I liked this artists work best; she was not only painting the scene as it lay before her, but she was also adding her own elements the elm tree and expressing her mood and thoughts at that particular time. By breaking the realist rules of the day, she was making a statement with her art.
Some twenty-five years later I would often reflect on those early lessons that had registered by way of an artist tolerating the relentless gawking of a kid with worms escaping his shirt pocket.
What I found particularly intriguing, however, was how the artist would start with a blank canvas and then add elements as their imagination desired. By comparison the photographer starts with a full canvas and eliminates those elements that are undesirable. Consequently we can say that a painters art form is an additive one, whereas a photographers is subtractive.
Over the next few issues let us explore some of the basic rules of composition by identifying the elements of pleasing aesthetics: the S-curve, the C-curve, how to create motion by using diagonals, forcing the viewer into the scene by way of using contrast and selective focus, how the use of triangles keep the eye moving within, and of course the time-honoured favourite of teachers everywhere the Rule of Thirds.
Once we have explored the possibilities these guidelines can bring to our photography, we will then become rebels and toss them aside. Only by understanding the rules can we then effectively break them.
In the interim, what I want you to do is start making pictures with an awareness of where you are placing your subject, and objectively pondering why you made that decision. There is no substitute for actually being out there enjoying the craft that made us acquire a camera in the first place. As you study your results ask if the image translates the message you were trying to make in the first place. This is not philosophical rhetoric there really was a reason you made that picture in the first place.
What was it?
Study and analyse your picture, and learn from your exercises. First and foremost, keep your picture making fun.
And remember, if you are having fun you are doing it right.